you think it’s like this but it’s really like this
Thursday, February 14th, 2008probably by now we’ve all seen juno. though i spent the first 20 minutes rolling my eyes to the obnoxious “i’m so cool, counterculture, and edgy” crap, it was entertaining and fun (i’ll admit, one scene activated the lacrymal glands). i was impressed with the performances of juno’s parents. they stole the show with LOLers like “when you move out I’m getting two weimaraners!” and “did you run someone over with the previa?!” what charmers!
of course, you may remember this line:
“you shoulda gone to china. you know, ’cause I hear they give away babies like free iPods. You know, they pretty much just put them in those T-shirt guns and shoot them out at sporting events.”
understandably, it offended a lot of folks, like this mother of two adopted daughters from china. hackles are up. one adoptee said,
“…to say that you can get them like iPods, like commodities, it’s speaking to the adoption industry, and it’s said in a really brutalizing way.”
jason reitman, the director, retorts:
“No one could be more sensitive to this idea than myself. My wife and daughter are Chinese, and my sister is adopted,” Reitman says. “While I am connected to this on all levels, I have always felt that it is important that we find humor in which we are most sensitive. It is through comedy that we can begin conversation instead of hiding behind political correctness – a wall that simply divides people and stifles communication.”
you get the drift. another somewhat polemical battleground rife with different angles, stories, and philosophies that make my head hurt. i took a race / ethnicity public policy course in college that induced this feeling for an entire semester. it was a good kind of discomfort, meant to strengthen your analytical mind and sharpen your argument skills. mostly though, it reminded me that rarely is anything simply black or white.
because i can’t enjoy this particular experience anymore in the classroom, i now derive it from comment sections accompanying online articles.
i highly suggest that you first read the article, then take a gander at the 152 (and growing) comments. if you ever want to take a pulse on how people really feel, just spend some time with their comments. diving into comment sections of hot topic articles has become a bad habit of mine. it’s mesmerizing yet frightening, and often leaves a bad taste in my mouth. i’m a jaded cynic, and sometimes even i am alarmed and shocked by the undercurrent of hostility and _____. on this topic, an overwhelming amount of people basically had a dismissive, apathetic “get over it” attitude, which quite frankly is a bit disconcerting, even for a non-PC person like me. and there was a handful of folks who took the opposite stance. here are a few salient selections from differing sides, some of which pissed me off:
The comment had some truth to it. Human life doesn’t mean much in China. China is the country that charges the family of the executed the cost of the bullet after they have been shot. I am sure there is a 1000% mark up on the bullet.
Don’t stop at the Olympics – boycott China. I meant it. We can make our own iPods and Wal Mart crap or get it someplace else. Millions of unwanted babies in China aren’t given away but mercilessly slaughtered. But, wait, there’s more. Anyone who talks democracy in that country gets an open-ended prison sentence, torture or a bullet in the back of the head.
Would it have been less offensive if they cracked on your driving abilities… Lighten up!
those of you who don’t get why people are offended… just ADMIT you don’t get why people are offended instead of telling them they have no reason to be offended or to tell them to lighten up. Admit you are ignorant and then this is where the dialogue begins.
People offended by the truth, thats funny.
The can of worms is open. I was in Beijing China last spring. I saw with own eyes a woman screaming at a small child and kicking this child on the back. The woman looked to be in her 50′s and I thought maybe the grandmother. But the child was small, maybe 4 or 5 and crying and scared and crowds of people walked by and went on with their lives and this woman was kicking this small child in the back and yelling at it. I know that if we were in the states at that moment this woman would have been tackled and arrested by complete strangers. I don’t mean to scrutinize the behavior of a stranger on the street, but I know what my eyes saw and it was not good for the chinese baby.
and that’s just the tip o’ the iceberg.
the thing is, i value humor more than anything, so that juno line elicited a chuckle while it simultaneously raised an eyebrow. the analogy of the easy availability of chinese babies to ipods and t-shirt cannons was clever (though false), and i get that it was intended to emphasize juno’s naivete, her know-it-all-but-not-having-lived-life demeanor. but at the same time…a few of these comments reveal how extremely stupid and eager people are to villify china. yes, people in china have no hearts and enjoy killing their babies…?!?!?!




































































